The Broker

Photo credits: 10b travelling / Carsten ten Brink

Knowledge to adapt

Bruce Campbell | 16 January 2013

New actors in the food security debate are communication specialists and software developers who are necessary for innovative ways to ensure that information reaches farmers and villages, says Bruce Campbell.

Climate change challenges – both the slow increase in temperatures and the increased severity and frequency of extreme events – are going to pose and are already posing major challenges to food security in developing countries. In a four-degree warmer world, vast areas of Africa will have more than 20% reductions in their growing season. Droughts, floods, unreliable seasons and unseasonable weather are already impacting farming operations. In order to achieve food security, climate change adaptation is crucial.

Farmers have been at the forefront of changes and “shocks” since time immemorial, so are well placed to counter climate change. However, “coping” is insufficient if food security is to be achieved. Farmers need to know what kind of season is coming, and thus what and when to plant. They need to know about the outbreak of new pests and diseases. On the longer term, they need to know whether a shift in crop species or different farming strategies are needed. A cornerstone of active adaptation is information availability: varieties to grow, diversification options, seasonal climate forecasts, flood and cyclone warnings, pest and disease outbreaks, market options. 

Public extension services in the agricultural sector in developing countries are essentially in crisis! There are insufficient resources to ensure that the needed information for adaptation reaches farmers and villages.

Fortunately, the explosion in cell phone ownership and coverage has provided some relief to information-poor farmers. It was unimaginable a few decades ago that cell phones would be as accessible as they are now to most rural farmers, even in remote rural areas. Our surveys in coastal Bangladesh show that 70% of households have access to phones. At a site in Kenya 70% of male farmers have access to cell phones, down to 45% for women farmers. Thus we have to be careful that new forms of communication do not reinforce social inequity. At a remote site in Ethiopia, access is down to about 30%. But, given the growth in coverage, such numbers are likely to double in the coming years.   

Cell phones by themselves are, of course, not enough. Now we need the creativity of scientists and communication specialists and software developers, working with farmers, to ensure that the messages reaching farmers are timely and appropriate for the specific contexts of different kinds of farmers. In Senegal, scientists and communications specialists have been working with farmers to understand the information needs of farmers and the best way of delivering the information. In Mali, scientists have studying how past efforts at climate services have or have not met the needs of farmers. We need mobile apps developers to turn their attention to the needs of smallholder farmers. All these local efforts need to feed into national and regional dialogues or policy processes, so that lessons can be scaled up and widely applied.  

India is leading in extension via cell phones. For example, India’s mobile phone system, which puts market data and weather forecasts in farmers’ hands now reaches millions of farmers. Elsewhere there are initiatives that use cell phones to facilitate crop insurance, bank transfers related to farming, identification of pests and diseases, and irrigation and fertiliser practices. Many are still experimental, but I think we are seeing the tip of the iceberg for a revolution in information provision to farmers in developing countries.

Other innovative ways of reaching farmers must also be explored. For example, Mbaitu FM, a local language radio station in Eastern Kenya aired a weekly programme “The Voice of the Farmer” to get farmers and experts in dialogue about climate change adaptation, and with audience participation through SMS or voice calls. In another initiative a television reality show in Kenya, called “Shamba Shape-up” (www.shambashapeup.com) reaches an audience of 7 million viewers. Farm experts select a smallholder farm and modernize it – similar to home remodeling shows in other countries. The show is backed-up by SMS or leaflet provision of information on the selected farming practices.

We see entertainment, communication and science coming together. We need more of that if we are to rise to the challenge of climate change.

Photo credit main picture: Photo credits: 10b travelling / Carsten ten Brink

Comments

Your comment will not be automatically posted but first reviewed by the editor. If the editor has questions with respect to the content of your comment, you will be contacted.

 

Bruce Makes Important Points

Now is the time for ingenuous communicators to leverage mobile phone explosion in Africa. Smart phones should be made cheaper - to allow exchange of photos, Videos etc by farmers. We must expand small holder farmers interaction beyond SMS. Farmers in Uganda and Kenya have also taken on Mobile Money services - to receive payments from their clients and pay for inputs - What will be the role of banks if they don't transform to fit new age trends. In upcountry Uganda, some banks are closing shop. Now, the efforts should be directed at making information/ knowledge easy for farmers to consume and deploy-- Meteorological services in Uganda should style up and provide accurate, relevant and timely information to farmers.
Morrison Rwakakamba | January 29, 2013 | Respond

Bruce Makes Important Points

Thanks for your excellent points. I think we will continue to see the decline of phone prices and costs of connecting, so I am hopeful the technology is going to spread, and that we can move beyond SMS. Who would have thought that banking by phone was possible in remote areas of Kenya and Uganda a decade ago? The trends are very positive. I am glad you raised the issue of national meteorological agencies needing to focus on getting good information to farmers. Our research program CCAFS is testing different methods of providing farmers with weather information, working closely with meteorological agencies in several African countries.
Bruce Campbell | February 19, 2013 |

Knowledge to adapt

Dear Mr.Bruce Campbell,
You are right to say that information about seasonal changes, new diseases outbreak and other will help farmers. You are also right in mentioning that 'the cornerstone of active adaptation is information availability: varieties to grow, diversification options, seasonal climate forecasts, flood and cyclone warnings, pest and disease outbreaks, market options.'
Climate change impacts threaten food security in different ways. In southern Bangladesh the threat is Cyclones and floods, In Sub Saharan Africa the threat is extended draught periods followed by heavy rainfalls.
Speaking from the perspective of small farmers in small villages in Kilema-Moshi for instance, availability of information is just a small step towards climate change adaptation. Other factors are necessary for adaptation. For example;
1. Knowledge and technology ; specifically sustainable ways of extending the shelf life of perishable agricultural products so as the farmers can be able to survive during hard times.
2. Sustainable transportation and infrastructure from farms to local markets.
3. Primary industries in local areas that will provide farmers with the much needed tools according to the challenges.
Indeed the services provided by mobile telephones are useful but indeed when speaking of food security it is necessary to try and understand the bigger picture otherwise it is very possible to make assumptions based on our knowledge and understanding of the problems.
Food security in developing countries is not only because of climate change impacts. It is affected by policies made on the international arena, by structural adjustment programs, and by WTO rules and regulations. A combination of all these factors, makes life for small farmers and low income groups a continues struggle with little light at the end of the tunnel.
In addition, demand for agricultural products from developing countries has created a situation whereby farmers seize the opportunity to raise prices for the exported products and charge the same price from the local people. These new prices are unaffordable to low income people i.e. in North Uganda. As a result, the problem of food security is exacerbated, leading to health impacts and increased financial stress as well as extreme poverty of the low income target groups.
Therefore what I am trying to say is ; there is no general solution for food security threats on national level or even regional level, it is necessary to find out the underlying causes , and we shouldn’t opt for a standardised climate change adaptation plan.
S.E.Tesha | January 22, 2013 | Respond

Tailored adaptation plans

Thanks for your reply. You are spot on. Each region and village will need to have very specific adaptation plans and activities. And, as you suggest, it will be a portfolio of activities that will be needed at each site. There will be no silver bullets. I very much liked how you stressed that activities will be needed in the whole food system, not just farming itself – transportation for markets, post-harvest storage etc. etc. And your point that one must also consider the policy context, with even international policies needing to be changed. Getting all these elements right is going to be one huge challenge! Given the need to tailor adaptation plans to local contexts we need to combine national policy and action with bottom-up planning processes.
Bruce Campbell | February 19, 2013 |