Current Issue
Debate
Special Reports
- Special Report: Greening the global economy
- Special Report: Cities of the world unite
- Special report: The power of value chains
- Special report: Social academia
- Special report: Who is the enemy?
- Special report: The rise of solar energy
- Special report: Health for all
- Special report: Deep democracy
- Special report: Wobbly legs
- Special report: The Dutch treatment
RSS Feeds
Navigating the Anthropocene
The Earth system is changing rapidly due to human activity. The scale of human interference with planetary systems is such that our time could be recognized as a new era in planetary history: the 'anthropocene'. The adverse impacts of human activities could, inadvertently, even change the Earth system irreversibly to a mode inhospitable to humans and other life. Navigating the anthropocene is thus a key challenge for policy makers and a challenge for (social) sciences because the institutions, organizations and governance systems by which humans currently govern their relationship with the environment are not only insufficient, but also poorly understood.
The 2009 Amsterdam Conference on the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change – 'Earth System Governance, People, Places, and the Planet', will be held on 2-4 December. The event brings together about 400 international scientists to address the fundamental and applied research challenge to develop integrated systems of governance, from the local to the global level, that can help to ensure the sustainable development of the coupled socio-ecological system that the Earth has become – that can support navigation through the anthropocene. The Broker web editor Louise Stoddard and a number of conference participants will contribute to this blog before, during and after the event.
Video interviews from Earth Systems Governance conference
December 23, 2009 Louise Stoddard
These videos show participants and speakers at the Earth Systems Governance conference taking part in ‘chair chat’, a structured interview about their perspectives from the event, filmed by Amy Hochstetler. For the full collection of interviews please visit the Earth Systems Governance website
Simon Wolf, Helmholtz Environmental Research Center, Germany
Joyeeta Gupta, Scientific Steering Committee, IHDP Earth System Governance Project; Scientific Steering Committee, ESSP Global Water System Project; and VU University Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Roberto Pereira Guimarães, Scientific Committee, vice chair, International Human Dimensions Programme on Global Environmental Change (IHDP); and the Getulio Vargas Foundation, Brazil
The earth system governance dream
December 07, 2009 Ruben Zondervan
Ruben Zondervan is the executive officer of the Earth System Governance Project and programme officer at the Secretariat of the International Human Dimensions Programme on Global Environmental Change, Bonn, Germany.
In the early evening of 4 December, the 2009 Amsterdam Conference came to an end with a closing plenary entitled 'The Earth System Governance Vision Factory: I Have a Dream'. Chaired by Frank Biermann and Roberto Pereira Guimaraes, this plenary was held in a slightly different, innovative and more dynamic format than is usually chosen. All the keynote speakers from the conference were invited to present their dream or vision of earth system governance for 2050. They were all given a maximum of two minutes and were allowed just one slide. The preparation process of this closing plenary session made clear that the limited time and number of slides posed a real challenge to the presenters. Or, as one keynote speaker remarked, it was 'one of the most intimidating things I ever had (to do)'.
The resulting vision factory of dreams was not intimidating at all, though. While being serious in content, the sequence of dreams was presented with a large amount of humour and creativity. The chairs presented some slides as ‘dreams by proxy’ of keynote speakers that already had to leave the conference venue – the global environmental governance community is a travelling circus, after all – and they commented on the other dreams. Although the participants were seriously tired after three days of research presentations, long evenings of networking, brainstorming and debating, the dreams, in their large variety and humorous presentation, excited the participants.
Some speakers stayed within the scientific realm by presenting dreams of specific target numbers and scenarios of earth system governance. Others transcended visions of imaginary reincarnations through the history and future of earth system governance, or shed new light on old stories, for instance by asking what would have happened if Moses had had to do an Environmental Impact Assessment before parting the waters of the Red Sea. Beautiful pictures of landscapes were presented that, as is possible in dreams alone, turned into symbols and graphs of a future with more sustainable governance and development. While the visions for earth system governance in 2050 were characterized by a positive, hopeful perspective, one keynote speaker said that given the reality, he would probably be woken up before his dreams come true. But, as Roberto Pereira Guimaraes remarked in his closing words, 'when you dream alone, it's just a dream, (…) but if you dream together, it is a pre-emption of reality'.
Climate environmental problems and economic growth
December 06, 2009 Pedro Fidelman
Pedro Fidelman is a research rellow at the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Australia, and fellow for the Earth System Governance Project. He is particularly interested in environmental governance, institutional analysis and common-pool resources.
On Friday morning, a very interesting panel discussion took place at the ESG conference. The panellists – Roberto Guimaraes, Maarten Hajer and James Meadowcroft – provided their views on ‘New Theories for Earth System Governance’. A key issue that I felt was missing from many discussions at the conference was raised by Guimaraes; that is, the influence of the global political economy on contemporary global environmental problems.
The current economic paradigm is based on the assumption that material growth equals progress. Not surprisingly, emerging economies such as China, India, Brazil and others are following the ‘recipes’ for progress, which adds to the demand for resources and provides a growing market for consumption. Such a paradigm has led to over-exploitation, degradation and, in many cases, the collapse of resource systems. ‘Progress’ has transformed the planet beyond recognition and put the earth’s life support system at great risk.
Averting catastrophic impacts, particularly those associated with climate change, will require changing our current economic paradigm. Economies cannot grow indefinitely in a world where resources are finite. Material growth no longer translates into quality of life, especially where it depends on the goods and services provided by ecosystems. In addition, the recent global economic crisis has proven that some assumptions in which the economy is based need revising. The free market ideology, for example, was considered flawed.
A major issue needing attention is how to promote, in a deliberate way, the needed economic transformation before it takes place (irrespectively) induced by crisis. What are your views? Please leave your comments below.
Pedro Fidelman is a research rellow at the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Australia, and fellow for the Earth System Governance Project. He is particularly interested in environmental governance, institutional analysis and common-pool resources. The terminology of the ESG conference include words like resilience, reflexive adaptation, social entrepreneurs, deliberation, climate change, multi-scale governance, climate policy integration, adaptive g... Read more>>
Democracy and earth system governance: empowered space and contestation
December 06, 2009 Kathrin Dombrowski
Kathrin Dombrowski is a PhD student in the Department of International Relations at the London School of Economics. According to John Dryzek, democracy is absolutely integral to effective earth system governance. We know from history that democracies have a better environmental track record than authoritarian states. However, it now seems that the type of democracy also matters. In his presentation, Dryzek pointed out that consensual democracies (found in Northern Europe and Japan) surpa... Read more>>
Three ways for social science to help the environment
December 06, 2009 Sara Hughes
Sara Hughes is a PhD candidate at the Bren School of Environmental Science & Management at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a fellow with the Earth System Governance project. Sara is in her fourth year of PhD work and is interested in the way our systems of government shape our cities. Her research focuses on urban planning and decision making, particularly in the area of water and wastewater services. I came to the 2009 Amsterdam Conference on Earth System Governanc... Read more>>
Diana Liverman, director of the Environmental Change Institute at Oxford University, talks with Louise Stoddard from The Broker about the upcoming climate change conference in Copenhagen and her article published today in Nature, which argues that we need a four degree reduction in global temperature to combat climate change. Read more>>
Video: Roberto Pereira Guimarães
December 04, 2009 Ana Marques
Roberto Pereira Guimarães talks to Louise Stoddard from The Broker about what Earth System Governance means in a practical sense and how climate change can be compared to the course of the Titanic. Read more>>
Agency and accountability
December 04, 2009 Kathrin Dombrowski
Kathrin Dombrowski is a PhD student in the Department of International Relations at the London School of Economics. The two semi-plenaries on agency and accountability, which were held consecutively on Thursday, complemented each other well and illustrated some of the ways in which these two ‘A’s of the Earth System Governance (ESG) Science Plan are interlinked. According to Michele Betsill, the key research questions relating to agency in earth system governance are the following: What... Read more>>
One for the road: ClimateGate, French wine and Copenhagen
December 04, 2009 Louise Stoddard
‘Martin Luther King did not say "I have a nightmare’’' warned Maarten Hajer in today’s session on 'New Theories for Earth System Governance. The recent ‘ClimateGate’ media coverage might seem like a nightmare for those who have been trudging the long, lobbying road to Copenhagen, but Hajer warns that the trick is in the media message. New theories of Earth System Governance have to take into account the impact that the media has on the public, and that positive messages are much more l... Read more>>
Amrita Lamba is a junior research fellow and doctoral candidate at the Centre for the Study of Law and Governance, Jawaharlal Nehru University, India I just about found some moments of soliloquy to pen my thoughts on what struck me most on the first day of the Amsterdam Conference on the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change. My focus will be on Professor Louis Lebel’s presentation on 'Inclusive, Deliberative and Adaptive: Changing How Water is Managed at Multiple Scales'.... Read more>>
Video: Frank Biermann at Earth System Governance Conference
December 03, 2009 Ana Marques
Frank Biermann from the Earth System Governance Project, SENSE Research School and VU University Amsterdam, the Netherlands, talks with The Broker. Read more>>
Video: Joyeeta Gupta at the Earth System Governance conference
December 03, 2009 Ana Marques
Joyeeta Gupta, professor of climate change law and policy at the Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam and of water law and policy at the UNESCO-IHE Institute for Water Education in Delft, talks with Louise Stoddard from The Broker about the problems associated with imposing paradigms of governance onto other states. The upcoming Copenhagen climate change conference is also discussed. Read more>>
Video: Michele M. Betsill at the Earth System Governance conference
December 03, 2009 Ana Marques
Michele Betsill is an associate professor at the Department of Political Science from the Colorado State University. Read more>>
Bureaucratic saturation of water management?
December 03, 2009 Sara Hughes
Sara Hughes is a PhD candidate at the Bren School of Environmental Science & Management at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a fellow with the Earth System Governance project. Sara is in her fourth year of PhD work and is interested in the way our systems of government shape our cities. Her research focuses on urban planning and decision making, particularly in the area of water and wastewater services. Water is one of the most important resources on the planet – it p... Read more>>
Architecture of forestry governance
December 03, 2009 Louise Stoddard
Louise Stoddard is the web editor for The Broker and a freelance writer and consultant based in Amsterdam Today's session on forestry governance highlighted the complexity behind the ambitions of Earth System Governance. KK Kaushal, Forestry Officer for the Government of India, first presented the example of Tamil Nadu, India, where the state has taken on a community involvement process to restock forests through the process of Joint Forest Management (JFM). JFM involves the establishmen... Read more>>
Where is the gender dimension?
December 03, 2009 Kathrin Dombrowski
Kathrin Dombrowski is a PhD student in the Department of International Relations at the London School of Economics. Isn’t there something missing? It occurred to me today that although there is lots of talk about vulnerability and justice at the conference, I have not come across any papers that look specifically at issues of gender. In fact, I noticed that the conference programme doesn’t mention the word ‘women’ (or ‘woman’) once. It’s an interesting omission given that women are often... Read more>>
Global and local earth system governance
December 02, 2009 Louise Stoddard
We arrived at Hotel Volendam this morning for the start of the Earth System Governance (ESG) conference to a glorious sunrise over the neighbouring cheese factory. If participants at the conference didn’t realize they were in the Netherlands before, then they sure do now. The plenary kicked off with Frank Biermann outlining the Earth System Governance Project, a ten-year plan with a focus on global, but also local level, governance. Frank briefly outlined the five different areas of foc... Read more>>
Kathrin Dombrowski is a PhD student in the Department of International Relations at the London School of Economics. In his opening statement, Frank Biermann mentioned that the word ‘governance’ comes up 961 times in the conference programme. The Earth System Governance Project is particularly interested in ‘new’ forms of governance, that is to say private forms of governance beyond the nation-state. Academic research on instances of rulemaking by private actors has really taken off in re... Read more>>
What does Earth System Governance offer for cities?
December 02, 2009 Sara Hughes
Sara Hughes is a PhD candidate at the Bren School of Environmental Science & Management at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a fellow with the Earth System Governance project. Sara is in her fourth year of PhD work and is interested in the way our systems of government shape our cities. Her research focuses on urban planning and decision making, particularly in the area of water and wastewater services. Today was the conference kick-off – and the excitement in the air... Read more>>
Climate change is the dominating issue
December 01, 2009 Kathrin Dombrowski
Kathrin Dombrowski is a PhD student in the Department of International Relations at the London School of Economics ‘Earth System Governance – People, Places, and the Planet’ is the theme of the 2009 Amsterdam Conference on the Human Dimension of Global Environmental Change, taking place this week (2-4 December). I was lucky to be accepted to participate in the PhD Winter School on ‘The Challenge of Adaptive Governance’, which preceded the conference and brought together about 32 PhD stud... Read more>>
Humans are part of the solution
December 01, 2009 Amrita Lamba
Amrita Lamba is a junior research fellow and doctoral candidate at the Centre for the Study of Law and Governance, Jawaharlal Nehru University, India Coming to grips with development that lasts has been an elusive search for humankind. While the discourse in social science has traipsed along the trajectory that saw newer ways of defining development, as sustainable development and now adaptive governance, it makes me ponder as a social scientist whether we are at all committed to amelio... Read more>>
Louise Stoddard is the web editor for The Broker and a freelance writer and consultant based in Amsterdam Last week, after completing my registration for the Amsterdam Conference on the Human Dimensions of Global Environmental Change, I went to see the new ‘ultimate disaster movie’ 2012 at the cinema. The storyline was poor, but the effects were horrifyingly impressive. Hawaii was turned into a luminous series of bubbling volcanoes and enormous floods; earthquakes and clouds of ash wiped... Read more>>
Linking academic knowledge of earth systems
November 30, 2009 Sara Hughes
Sara Hughes is a PhD candidate at the Bren School of Environmental Science & Management at the University of California, Santa Barbara, and a fellow with the Earth System Governance project. Sara is in her fourth year of PhD work and is interested in the way our systems of government shape our cities. Her research focuses on urban planning and decision making, particularly in the area of water and wastewater services. As a PhD student at the University of California, Santa Barbar... Read more>>
Key issues on the Earth System Governance agenda
November 30, 2009 Pedro Fidelman
Pedro Fidelman is a research rellow at the ARC Centre of Excellence for Coral Reef Studies, James Cook University, Australia, and fellow for the Earth System Governance Project. He is particularly interested in environmental governance, institutional analysis and common-pool resources December is shaping up to be an important month for the debate, and hopefully some decisions and actions too, on global environmental change. From the 7th of December, environmental ministers and officials... Read more>>
Photos from the conference
Photos taken at the Earth Systems Governance Conference are available from The Broker's Flickr feed HERE
This blog's Twitter feed
- thebrokeronline: Commentators debate the recent WRR report and the future of Dutch aid on The Broker: http://tinyurl.com/ydzenst (Thu, 21 Jan 2010 10:04:25 +0000)
- thebrokeronline: Why the Dutch should have thought twice about supporting invasion of Iraq: new blog on The Broker: http://tinyurl.com/yhsh94q (Wed, 13 Jan 2010 13:29:59 +0000)
- thebrokeronline: How progressive is Hillary Clinton’s ‘modernization of aid’? New blog from Frans Bieckmann on The Broker: http://tiny.cc/bpgo6 (Tue, 12 Jan 2010 09:40:51 +0000)
- Follow this feed...
Navigating the Anthropocene
- Blog post: Video interviews from Earth Systems Governance conference (December 23, 2009)
- Comment: Adaptivess interrogated (December 23, 2009)
- Comment: Water Resource Management (December 20, 2009)
- Blog post: The earth system governance dream (December 07, 2009)
- Blog post: Three ways for social science to help the environment (December 07, 2009)
- Blog post: Democracy and earth system governance: empowered space and contestation (December 06, 2009)
- Blog post: It is about commitment (December 06, 2009)
- Blog post: Climate environmental problems and economic growth (December 06, 2009)
- Blog post: One for the road: ClimateGate, French wine and Copenhagen (December 04, 2009)
- Blog post: Agency and accountability (December 04, 2009)
- Blog post: Video: Roberto Pereira Guimarães (December 04, 2009)
- Blog post: Video: Diana Liverman (December 04, 2009)
- Comment: One example from the conference (December 04, 2009)
- Blog post: Where is the gender dimension? (December 03, 2009)
- Blog post: Architecture of forestry governance (December 03, 2009)
- Blog post: Bureaucratic saturation of water management? (December 03, 2009)
- Blog post: video: Michele M. Betsill at the Earth System Governance conference (December 03, 2009)
- Blog post: video: Joyeeta Gupta at the Earth System Governance conference (December 03, 2009)
- Blog post: video: Frank Biermann at Earth System Governance Conference (December 03, 2009)
- Blog post: Changing water management (December 03, 2009)

